Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Mental Crack at Westlake #2

A huge group turned out for Westlake #2. The "A" field had nearly 50 riders. The "B" field probably had 20. The sky was perfectly blue, and there was a light headwind on the back stretch out of the east north east. The temperature was about 60 degrees at the start.

I was feeling pretty confident after last week's successful mission, but a little weary after a couple of hard rides over the weekend, so my goal was just to finish with the group.

The pace of the race was faster than last week. We hit 30+ mph on almost every lap through the start finish area. I actually felt pretty good most of the time, but ended up at the back of the field on a regular basis. The large group made it difficult to move up, and even when I managed to move up five or six ranks in the field, I didn't manage to hold position. However, the accordian effect wasn't really that bad.

On the 13th of 19 laps, I just ran out of gas. I sprinted out of the corner onto Ranney parkway like normal, caught the field, like normal, but just wasn't able to muster the energy to crank up the speed when an attack went off the front and the field accelerated, so I just rolled around to the parking lot and cruised home early.

It will take a few more outings to build up the muscular endurance to ride at that pace for longer than an hour. But I think my aerobic fitness is pretty good. I'll also cut the volume down on the Sunday rides so I'm fresh for the race.

Monday, May 11, 2009

Power Meter Research

I've been using my iBike Power Meter since 2006. Although it works reasonably well, it has some weaknesses that cause me to sometimes doubt the data that's collected during a ride. Also, reading about the new Quarq power meter has got me thinking about buying a new one.

First, I should clarify what I'm trying to accomplish by forking out the cash for a new power meter. I'm looking to improve the reliability of measurements from my iBike, or rather, eliminate my doubts about those measurements. Let's assume my iBike is 90% accurate as a function of time due to fluctuation in my position on the bike, or inaccurate wind speed measurements. The questions are is that even an issue? If so, how much money is that really worth?

Here is a comparison of Powertap, Quarq, and iBike. Well, there's not much difference between the measurements. The idea that more money = better performance might not have basis in fact. So if I buy a new force transducer type power meter, I might still have doubts about the data that I collect.

iBike

Some iBike reviews:
Is there any merit in upgrading the iBike to one of the newer versions? The top of the line iBike is about $900 by the time you add all the options. That's starting to get into PowerTap territory. What new features does it have that justify the extra long green.
  • Wireless
  • ANT+ Compatibility
  • ability to combine data from multiple sources, like GPS, HRM, and a force transducer power meter with novel calculations.
  • Faster CPU, more accurate
The new iBike Stem Mount is a better solution that the bar mount that I currently have. The stem is less susceptible to vibration than the bars, plus the central location should be a better representation of air pressure differential than the offset position.

SRM

SRM is the gold standard power meter, but costs like it's made out of gold. At $3,000-4,000 more or less, there's no way I can justify that. Let's presume it's 100% accurate. What value does the theoretical 10% have when my power data is only comprehensible when viewed through the hazy lens of subjective personal experience? Moving on!

Power Tap

The PowerTap is more reasonably priced (by far) than the SRM. One advantage over the iBike, is I could use the power meter with my cyclocross bike. On the other hand, one of the things I like about 'cross is that I don't use a computer at all. At that point of the season, I'm typically weary of analyzing power data and chasing after digits on a computer.

The problem with the PowerTap is that I would only be able to collect data with new wheels. I'd probably want a training set and a racing set, and a cyclocross set! So the price tag of the PowerTap solution gets steep quickly. The computer is about $300, and each hub is about $900 for the fancy version. Also, I just bought new wheels, so those just collect dust when I want to measure power. If I were about to upgrade wheels, that would be the time to think about a PowerTap.

Quarq

I like the Quarq power meter approach. It's got the advantages of force transducer measurement without the hassle. It's wireless, ANT+ compatible, and the electronics and battery are easily accessible. Plus, they are planning to release a bike computer with open source software! For me, that's awesome. Unfortunately, that's not available yet, but will cost about $1000. The price of the Quarq gauge is $1,495, plus you need to either supply cranks, or buy them from Quarq.

Only three crank types are currently compatible with the Quarq transducer, so I'd need to buy new cranks, so the price is more like $1,900 for the transducer and another grand for the computer. Ouch. $3,000.

I'll wait on that until they have the complete kit, transducer plus computer, and reconsider.

Ergomo

Ergomo seems like an interesting solution, but has loads of bad reviews from actual customers. That tells me stay way far away from it.

Bottom Line

Of the force transducer power meters, the Quarq power meter intrigues me. I don't like the limited crank set choices. I like the open source platform concept for the computer, though, and would be willing to pay to play around with that, since I'm a geek. The cost for the whole solution is steep, close to $3,000.

The new iBike is supposed to be more accurate than my first generation version. At $800-900 it's not bank breaking. But it will still have some of the deficiencies of my current unit.

If I get a windfall, I might spring for an iBike Gen III this summer, and in the meantime, I'll keep an eye on Quarq.





Thursday, May 7, 2009

Stormy Leroy

I headed up to Leroy after lunch today to do my TT workouts since a huge rain storm was moving in from the west. That meant there was a big wind out of the west, so it was a headwind on the return leg. The temperature was about 60F, and the humidity was as high as it can get without raining.

I did a quick warm up and saw Jim Behrens was out on the course riding in the opposite direction. The TT will start officially next Thursday (May 14).

My strategy for this effort was to push as hard as possible on the second, uphill leg of the course to try to steal some time from my season best 21:03, but more importantly, to increase my average power output for the effort closer to 400W.

I started out with a manageable pace. The tailwind on the outbound leg provided a little boost, I did a few out of the saddle efforts over the slightly steeper rises to boost the speed. I held back a little so I could push harder on the climb toward the turnaround. I took the corner fast, and pushed as hard as I could up the first section of the climb. The power meter was reading between 375 and 400W. That's about as hard as I can go and I could feel my brain starting to melt. On the second false flat section of the climb, I struggled to keep pushing at that pace, but by the climb before the turn I was able to get out of the saddle and sprint over the top.

I rolled through the turn around, then started ramping back up toward 350-400W for the return leg. I wasn't feeling the west wind until I got to the turn, then it was a real struggle on the way back in.

Over the last mile, I thought I had a chance to finally crack 21 minutes, and started pushing as hard as possible using the waltz technique, and shut the power display off. Reviewing the file, I kept it well over 400W and 25 mph in spite of the headwind. Once the finish line was in sight, I tried to accelerate all the way to the finish, but cracked about 50m before the line. I posted a 21:19 time and 353W average!

My calculated power output from the tackle the tower climb was 384W, but that was only 6 minutes. I'd like to post a 400W average for the Leroy course before the end of the season, so I'm on track.

I am starting to think about investing in a new power meter. The ibike works pretty well, but I'm always skeptical of good results!

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Westlake #1 Race Report

This was my first Westlake "A" race. I felt really cheerful at the start of the race and didn't have any pre-race jitters.  John V and Rick B also made the switch, which gave me a little mental boost.

My only goal was to finish with the field and to observe how the faster group reacts to attacks and counter attacks.

The course was pretty banged up from the winter freeze and thaw. Gwenn and Chris went around prior to the race and marked the more dangerous sections of pavement with fluorescent paint. Most of the time it was possible to see the holes and make minor course corrections, but I still had to bunny hop a couple of times, and managed to find a couple holes but didn't damage my tires or wheels.

The race started off with a couple of parade laps to give everyone a chance to learn where the bad sections of pavement were. I got up to the front and took some pulls to get warmed up. The racing really started after a few laps, there were a flurry of attacks until a break got established. I followed wheels near the front of the race while the attacks were going. I was a little too winded to grab a wheel and jump across. I caught my breath and tried to bridge, but only made it about half way across the gap.

Once the break was up the road, there were a succession of attempts to bridge, and the field chased them all down. Finally, the break got out of sight, and the field settled into tempo riding. The race ended with a practice sprint. I just watched them go for it and was happy to finish with the group.

I averaged 24.6 mph, average power was 250 Watts. I only felt under pressure a couple of times near the beginning of the race while the break was forming. I conserved plenty of energy and fatigue by spinning a smaller gear than I typically do. My bike handling brain finally clicked on. At the CB races, I felt like I was fighting the bike. After 30+ high speed turns at Westlake, I started to feel the lines through corners and was pedalling through most of the turns.

It was a relief to finally finish with the field and to actually participate in the race instead of hanging on for dear life.

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Running the Sahara

I dropped in at MRC Chardon today to pick up my re-trued wheels. We got into a conversation about touring across the US by bike. That's something I'll try someday, but for now, I like riding fast more than riding far. I have a hard time imagining the endless stretches of two lane road like route 6 through Ashtabula county.

That jogged my memory (no pun intended) about the documentary Running the Sahara about a group of ultra-marathoners who jog the entire Sahara desert. It was a remarkable achievement to travel that distance on foot. The movie is worth watching, even though it's a little dull at times. The steadily deteriorating relationship of the three runners is interesting to watch.

Monday, May 4, 2009

First Month Review

The first month of racing is over. I did three consecutive weekends of the Covered Bridge race. In review, there are some good lessons to take away from those.

In the second race, I was over my head. The pace was too high for me to stay in the field for long. The data from that race can be analyzed as a ceiling for my current fitness level. In the first and the third race, I was actually pretty comfortable, even with the sprints over the two little hills. That's good news, considering I still weigh 223 pounds. By mid season, I'll be around 200 pounds, so my power per kg will increase by another 10%.

My descending skills are non-existent and that prevented me from finishing with the field in the first and third races. I got the hang of the curvy downhill section before the bridge by the last race of the series, but never really mastered the off camber sweeper. I need to spend a lot more time polishing those skills throughout this season, then next year, I need to work on that early in the year. So I'll add a skills day to my training each week, and do that on a recovery ride. The MidOhio race will call on those skills, and that's coming up soon.

I need to add some 1x1 intervals to the training mix, and 15 sec microinterval sessions. So a typical mix of workouts during the week will be.

  • Saturday: 1x1, 8 reps, 3 sets, or 15 sec (1 hour to 90 mins)
  • Sunday: Long ride (2-3 hours)
  • Monday: Skills (1 hour)
  • Tuesday: Westlake (1-2 hours)
  • Wednesday: Rest
  • Thursday: Leroy TT (2 hours)
  • Friday: Rest

So a total amount of training for a week would be 7-10 at the peak, with high intensity. On race weeks, I'll omit or shorten rides.

Saturday, May 2, 2009

To "B" or not to "B"

The Westlake Training Series is set to start on May 5. For the past few seasons, I've been riding in the "B" field. I've been steadily improving my fitness since I started racing and riding again in 2005. 

It's time for me to switch from the "B" race to the "A" race. I don't think I can gain any fitness from riding the "B" field again this year. I know the "A" race average speed is 26-27 mph while the B field only averages about 24 on a fast night. I'm confident I could average 24 by myself for quite a long time on that course with my current level of fitness.

The drawback to riding the A race, is it's going to be the equivalent of motorpacing for me, rather than racing. Hopefully I'll be able to stay in the field, even if I'm dropped I'll keep doing the A race for the first month of the Westlake season.